top of page

Startup Loans: Bank Strategies To Mitigate High Borrower Credit Risks

With approximately 4.4 million new businesses emerging annually worldwide, entrepreneurship appears more attainable than ever. Cloud storage and open-source technologies drive down software development expenses, and the trend toward remote work is gaining momentum and reducing office-related costs.

However, despite these favorable circumstances, securing funding remains the primary hurdle for startup growth. Most of these startups rely primarily on self-funding, followed by support from business angels and venture capital funds.

Notably, traditional banks do not occupy a prominent position in this list, often shying away from extending loans to startups due to the perceived high credit risk associated with them.

Financing: A Crucial Challenge for Startups

Very few startups are exempt from this reality: substantial capital is a prerequisite for developing innovative products and solutions. Often, it entails several months, if not years, of research and development (R&D) before a marketable product emerges.

Consequently, during their initial years, startups typically expend significant resources on overhead, hiring skilled personnel and creating prototypes while generating little revenue.

At their inception, startups often receive support from organizations and initiatives championed by governments that promote the financing of young entrepreneurs. However, new challenges emerge between their second and third years of existence.

Scaling startups confront significant financial hurdles despite desperately requiring funds to finalize their product development or accelerate commercial expansion.

Indeed, even if a startup generates some revenue, it still needs substantial capital to facilitate rapid growth.

Only after a few years can it realistically aspire to attain profitability and self-finance its continued development.

To address this pressing need, many startups turn to venture capital funds or seek assistance from business angels. These entities are well-versed in assuming risks and are attuned to the unique dynamics of startups, in contrast to traditional banks.

Banks Remain Hesitant To Extend Loans to Startups

Failing to repay a startup loan has significant consequences, just like failure to settle a home loan. While nonpayment of a home mortgage can lead to foreclosure, inability to pay a startup loan may result in losing assets or collateral put up to secure the credit.

The core responsibility of a banker lies in the prudent management of credit risk. A bank must ensure that any borrower, whether an individual or a company, possesses the capacity to repay the loan as stipulated in the contractual terms.

Credit risk analysis

Typically, credit risk analysis heavily relies on financial data. In the case of a company, the bank scrutinizes aspects such as revenue, indebtedness, and cash flow.

Unfortunately, this conventional approach poses challenges when dealing with startups.

Remember, startups require substantial capital for their development, and generating revenue can be time-consuming. Early-stage startups often need more financial data to present to a bank.

Furthermore, during the research and development (R&D) phase, it remains to be seen whether the startup will attract clients or if its product will find market acceptance. Statistically, around 90% of startups fail, with only about 18% of first-time startups achieving success.

Startups needing more assets

In addition to this heightened risk, startups frequently need more assets or guarantees to offer to banks. Many entrepreneurs are recent graduates or professionals who need help to provide personal guarantees.

Moreover, startups may not possess tangible assets to serve as collateral, especially in today's digital age, where many products are intangible, such as Software as a Service (SaaS) or mobile applications.

The central banks and governments across the globe implemented substantial and extensive stimulus initiatives to mitigate the pandemic-related disruptions.

What constitutes a high-risk business loan?

A high-risk business loan is a final recourse for businesses deemed excessively risky according to conventional lending criteria.

When evaluating a business's eligibility for a loan, traditional lenders assess its creditworthiness using the five C's of credit: character, capital, capacity, conditions, and collateral.

If a business falls short in any of these aspects, it is classified as high-risk, making it difficult to secure a conventional business loan. Consequently, such companies must explore alternative financing options.

Common Varieties of High-Risk Business Financing

Numerous funding options are accessible to high-risk businesses, but assessing their suitability for your specific needs is crucial.

High-risk loans should serve as short-term solutions for addressing temporary working capital shortages. Here are various types of high-risk business loans worth considering:

Merchant cash advance

Merchant cash advance providers assess your eligibility based on credit card transactions, cash flow, business history, and credit score.

They typically require a credit score of over 525 and an annual cash flow of at least $180,000. Aside from that, MCAs are often granted to businesses that have been in operation for at least two years. .

Invoice financing

This option is tailored for business owners with outstanding unpaid invoices, especially those with extended remittance terms (e.g., 30 days or longer).

Invoice factoring companies purchase your accounts receivables and advance you a portion of their value.

Lenders often assess your clients' creditworthiness instead of your own to verify their track record of timely bill payments.

Short-term loan

Short-term loans represent a more conventional high-risk lending option with a maturity period of 18 months or less.

The shorter repayment timeline gives lenders greater confidence in lower default risk than traditional loans.

These loans may be obtainable from banks, credit unions, or alternative lenders, typically requiring a personal credit score of 550 or higher.

Businesses should have at least one year of operation and a minimum annual sales revenue of $50,000.

Personal loan

For startups needing a credit history and minimal annual revenue, a personal loan can be a viable option when adhering to its terms. Securing a personal loan requires a high credit score from banks, credit unions, or online lenders.

Credit card

Businesses with lower credit scores and sales revenue may find securing a business credit card easier, albeit with potentially higher interest rates.

Some credit cards offer cash-back incentives or an introductory 0% APR, making them a more cost-effective choice in certain situations.

Subprime business loans and equipment financing

Subprime loans help borrowers with poor credit scores or unfavorable borrowing histories. Borrowers typically rejected by prime-rate lenders may explore subprime options for financing.

While referred to as "subprime," these loans often carry higher interest rates.

Hard money loan

A hard money loan is a form of financing in which the loan amount is determined by the value of the collateral you provide, often real estate. Typically, the loan amount is a percentage of the appraised value of the collateral.

In hard money lending, the importance of your collateral's value outweighs factors like your credit score or borrowing history.

The risk of hard money loans is that their elevated interest rates can render them excessively expensive if you can repay them slowly.

Asset-based loan

An asset-based loan encompasses any loan that you secure by offering collateral. Hard money loans and other secured loans fall within this category.

This broader category encompasses various financing options such as term loans, SBA loans, and business lines of credit. Equipment, inventory, and invoice financing also fall under this description.

Regardless of your specific asset-based loan, the risk is evident: failing to repay the loan could result in seizing your assets as collateral.

It's essential for businesses considered high-risk to carefully evaluate these financing options and their associated terms, choosing the most viable solution for their specific circumstances.

Reasons To Promote Bank Loans for Startups

Encouraging bank loans to startups offers various advantages for both parties involved:

Capital preservation

Loans allow startups to limit the dilution of their ownership and retain control over their management. This is particularly valuable for founders and initial shareholders who wish to maintain a significant stake in the company.

Valuation enhancement

Loans can serve as a bridge between fundraising rounds, enabling startups to negotiate a higher valuation in subsequent funding rounds. It can lead to more favorable terms when seeking additional equity investments.

Venture debt

Venture debt, which falls between traditional debt and equity financing, provides startups access to capital while minimizing dilution. It offers flexibility in managing cash flow and growth without giving up ownership.

Client portfolio expansion

Banks benefit by adding high-potential startups to their client portfolio. Startups represent the future market and long-term growth potential.

As these startups evolve into mid to large-sized companies, they may require a range of banking services, such as account management, international expansion support, and export assistance. Banks can establish the foundation for a mutually beneficial and enduring customer relationship by providing loans.

Networking opportunities

Banks can facilitate growth by connecting startups with their network of partners and suppliers. It can open doors to collaboration, strategic partnerships, and access to resources that startups may not have independently.

Enhancing the relationship between banks and startups is essential. Banks can play a pivotal role in supporting startups' growth and success by providing financing and valuable services, fostering a mutually beneficial partnership that extends into the long term.

Enhancing Credit Risk Assessment for Startups

Assessing the credit risk of startups requires a more nuanced approach that considers their unique characteristics. Relying solely on traditional financial data is often inadequate, especially given the early stages of many startups and the potential for misleading information.

Here are some strategies for improving the assessment of credit risk for startups:

Holistic evaluation

Look beyond financial metrics and consider non-financial factors that can significantly impact a startup's success. It includes the quality of the management team, the market potential for their product or service, the competitive landscape, and the startup's strategic vision.

Market research

Conduct in-depth market research to gauge the startup's product or service demand. Understanding market trends, potential customers, and competitors can provide valuable insights into the startup's growth prospects.

Business plan evaluation

Scrutinize the startup's business plan, paying attention to the feasibility of their revenue projections, cost structure, and scalability. Assess whether the plan demonstrates a clear path to profitability.

Operational due diligence

Investigate the startup's operations and internal processes. Evaluate their ability to execute business plans, manage resources effectively, and adapt to changing market conditions.

Management team

Assess the experience and expertise of the startup's management team. A solid and capable leadership team is crucial for navigating startups' challenges.

Customer feedback

Seek feedback from potential customers, early adopters, or pilot programs to gauge the market's reception of the startup's product or service.

Industry analysis

Consider the specific industry in which the startup operates. Some industries may have more extended gestation periods or higher levels of risk, which should be factored into the risk assessment.

Scenario analysis

Conduct a scenario analysis to assess the startup's performance under different market conditions and potential setbacks. It helps in understanding the startup's resilience.

Track record

If available, review the startup's track record, including any previous ventures by the founders and their outcomes. Past successes or failures can provide valuable insights.

Peer comparison

Compare the startup to similar companies in size, industry, and stage of development. It can help assess whether the startup's financial and operational metrics align with industry norms.

Continuous monitoring

Recognize that credit risk assessment for startups is an ongoing process. Regularly monitor the startup's performance, financial health, and market dynamics to adjust risk assessments as needed.

More Support for Startups is Necessary

Indeed, financing is one of the most common reasons startups couldn’t expand their operations. Instead of shooting these businesses down before they can soar, lending institutions should give them a chance.

By adopting a more comprehensive and forward-looking approach that considers financial and non-financial factors, lenders and investors can better assess the credit risk associated with startups, reducing the likelihood of misjudging their potential for success.

Fuel Your Startup Journey - Subscribe to Our Weekly Newsletter!

Thanks for submitting!

bottom of page