• Team Startup Booted

How to Calculate the Fair Market Value of Your Stock Compensation?

If you're a shareholder in a company and have been receiving stock compensation, you might be wondering how private companies calculate the fair market value of the stocks. Well, 409A valuation is a term often used to describe this process of determining the FMV. The 409A valuation process is quite common for private companies; having said that, a company that has stock compensations and the shareholders that receive them will have to comply with this 409A regulation. As you know, this regulation is a part of the Internal Revenue Code. It is meant to make sure that the company accurately values the stock compensation of its shareholders. In this article, you will be learning more about the 409A valuation process and how you can use it to determine the FMV of your stock compensation.

Fair Market value of Stock Compensation

Fair Market value of Stock Compensation


Stock compensation refers to the share of a company that is issued to employees in the form of a part of employee benefits such as restricted stock units (RSUs), employee stock option plans (ESOP), stock purchase plans, etc. This is for the purpose of providing incentives for the employees to work harder, perform better and stay in the company. As such, the market price of stocks in private companies is not readily available when compared to public companies.


The fair market value of private companies' stocks is determined by a procedure called 409A valuation. It is essential in a private company that the company accurately values the stock compensation in order for them to be compliant with the Internal Revenue Code. Private companies may seek the help of a 409A valuation expert to determine the fair market value of the stocks. Thus, it is important that you know the procedure of the 409A valuation and establishes whether it aligns with the Internal Revenue Code.


Why do you need to calculate the FMV of your stock compensation?


When it comes to determining the fair market value of stock compensation, you need to know what kind of stocks you have. When we talk about stocks, we refer to a company's shares. A private company's stock may be under the control of management and the board members, while a public company's stocks are listed on the stock exchange. Determining the fair market value of your stocks will ensure that your stock compensation is fairly and accurately valued.


This will protect you and all the other shareholders in the company. In addition, the transparency of the company's financial statements will be improved. As such, the company will also be able to comply with the rules and regulations. Overall, having a 409A valuation process will allow you to know that your stock compensation is fairly valued.


Understand FMV and Taxation


In the context of determining a 409A valuation, we should be able to understand "fair market value" or "FMV". This term is widely used in the financial industry in regard to stock compensation. In the IRS's view, the fair market value of stock compensation is the price that is reasonable under the circumstances.


For instance, the fair market value of restricted stock units is the number that reflects the value of a company's stock. The fair market value is determined by using the methods prescribed by the IRS. In essence, fair market value is the price of the company's stock that reflects its true worth from a financial viewpoint. As such, the tax liabilities from the stock compensation will be in accordance with the fair market value. Thus, the fair market value of the stocks will determine how the company pays taxes on stock compensation.

How to calculate the FMV of stock compensation?


All private companies should determine the fair market value of the stocks by using the 409A valuation. The 409A valuation specialist must be capable of conducting 409A valuations and is required to have special knowledge of the IRS's rules and regulations. As such, the foundation of stock compensation is the value of the company's stock as determined by the 409A valuation. Moreover, 409A calculators are available on the internet. Therefore, you can easily calculate the FMV of your stock compensation. However, it is essential that you have a clear understanding of the 409A valuation process and how you can use it to determine your fair market value in private companies.


Calculate FMV with 409A valuation


A 409A valuation is a very important part of the private companies and their shareholders because it is important to ensure that the fair market value of stock compensation is determined. We should be able to learn how to calculate the FMV of stock compensation from the Internal Revenue Code 409A. In the Act, a special provision explains how a company should calculate the fair market value of stock compensation. Once we have understood this procedure, we will be able to get our answer and define some terms that are used in this phase.


The IRS has provided different methods for determining the FMV of stock compensation in order to ensure that every private company complies with 409A regulations. While basic calculations, assumptions, comparisons, and other factors are crucial to the process. We will understand the various methods to calculate FMV of stock compensation and look at the importance of 409A valuation in the following sections.


How does a 409A valuation help?


When dealing with private companies and their stock compensation, fair market value is a very important concept. This is because it is important that the company accurately values its stocks. This is because the company will be able to comply with 409A regulations and ensure that the stock compensation is fairly valued. This will be beneficial for all of the shareholders in private companies and improve transparency. A 409A valuation will also provide a safeguard against fraudulent stock compensation when the employees sell their stock at a greater value than the company's shares are currently worth. Moreover, it ensures that there is a proper administration of the taxes and that the company complies with the regulations. While in the absence of a 409A valuation, stock compensation will be out of compliance and may lead to heavy penalties.


Methods to use to calculate FMV


In private companies, the fair market value of the stocks will significantly impact the company's financial outcome. As such, you need to determine the fair market value of your stock. In order to ensure this, you will consider various methods that 409A valuation specialists use. Here are a few methods to effectively determine the fair market value of your stock:

  • Income Approach - The Income Approach is the most popular method that is used in 409A valuation. This approach uses a company's future cash flow and assumes that the company will generate a steady income for the future. As such, cash flows for 5 years are used to value the stock compensation. In this approach, all assumptions made must be consistent with the future cash flows expected by a company. It is also important that you consider the projected economic environment, inflation rates, and market conditions.

  • Market Approach - This approach involves using comparable public companies to value the fair market value of stocks. In this approach, you will assume that the company's stock price will be at or near the valuation of public companies that are similar to the company. The market approach is in compliance with the IRS and market standards. However, it is essential that there is a match between the private company's proportional share and the comparable public companies.

  • Asset-Based Approach - Under this approach, assets are valued and then used as a basis to calculate the fair market value of the company's shares. Tangible assets such as inventory, buildings, machines, and other physical assets. On the other hand, intangible assets like patents, copyrights, and trademarks are considered in this approach. Since assets are inherent, they could be liquidated at any time and will be adjusted for depreciation. As a result, the fair market value of assets could be used for determining the value of stock compensation.

  • Backsolve Method - In the Backsolve method, companies with complex capital structures are able to better calculate the fair market value of their stocks. For such companies, when no transactions are taking place during the valuation period, the Backsolve method will be used to determine the FMV of stocks. This method considers the most recent price paid for an investment in preferred shares to calculate the stock's value. Therefore, after identifying the value of the preferred share, you would be able to get the value of common shares.

Difficulties you may get while calculating FMV of your stock compensation


When you have decided to calculate the FMV of your stock compensation, you must consider some factors and challenges that may affect the 409A valuation process. Here are a few challenges that you must consider when calculating the FMV of your stock compensation:

  • When using the income approach of 409A, it is important that you make the assumptions relevant to the future cash flows of a company. The assumptions must be realistic, and the value of stock compensation must be properly calculated.

  • In a market approach, the company's stock price will be taken from a universe of public companies that are comparable to the private company in question. Well, if these companies are not similar to the private company you are dealing with, then you may end up with an inaccurate result.

  • In the asset-based approach of 409A, the different types of assets should be properly valued. In case you are not able to get the correct valuation of assets, the total FMV of the company will not be accurate.

Hence, it is important that you hire a qualified firm or a professional who will be able to assist you with the process of determining the FMV of your stock compensation.


Conclusion


The final conclusion that could be drawn from this article is that the 409A valuation is a process that allows you to determine the fair market value of your stock compensation. This method is highly preferred in private companies, ensuring that stock compensation is fairly valued. Furthermore, it helps in compliance with IRS regulations and ensures that all employees are given a proper form of compensation. In order to make the most out of this process, you must ensure that you hire an expert firm or an individual who will be able to assist you with this process.